Retail · Rochester, New York

Jay Scutti Plaza

300 & 1000 Hylan Drive, Rochester, NY 14623 · Google Maps

Jay Scutti Plaza is financed with a $36.0M CMBS loan at 4.90% that reached maturity on February 6, 2026, 8 months ago. As of the October 2026 10-D reports of CSAIL 2016-C6 Commercial Mortgage Trust and Citigroup Commercial Mortgage Trust 2016-C2, its status is with the special servicer. These trusts were issued before late 2016 and file no loan-level ABS-EE data, so the figures here are their monthly reports' and prospectuses'. What they report.

The loan

Balance on the 10-D of October 19, 2026
$36,004,872
Actual balance, on the 10-D
$36,033,555
Paid through, on the 10-D
October 6, 2026
Original balance (same notes)
$41,400,000
Interest rate
4.90%
Originated
January 8, 2016
Maturity
February 6, 2026
Payments
Interest only for 36 months, then amortizing
Master servicer
KeyBank National Association
Originator
MC - Five Mile

Status on the 10-D of October 19, 2026

Payment status
Performing matured balloon: no code printed (the statement's Delinquency Loan Detail lists only loans behind on their payments, and its Historical Detail counts this one neither in foreclosure nor as REO), paid through October 6, 2026, past its maturity date
Special servicing
On the trust's specially serviced list, transferred April 7, 2026
Workout strategy
Full Payoff

The property

Address
300 & 1000 Hylan Drive, Rochester, NY 14623
Metro
Rochester, NY
Rentable area
288,971 sq ft
Largest tenants at securitization
Value City Furniture; Toys “R” Us; AC Moore
Value at securitization
$60.0M (Jul 2015)

Performance

Underwritten figures against the most recent reported figures
MeasureAt securitizationLatest (Dec 2025)
DSCRn/a0.99x
Occupancy96%n/a
Net operating income$3.5M$2.8M
Debt yield7.8%

Debt yield here is the latest NOI divided by the balance held in the trusts below. If part of the loan sits outside them, the true figure is lower.

Figures at securitization are the prospectus's (Annex A-1). The latest column has what the trust's 10-D prints for this loan: net operating income for January 1, 2025 to December 31, 2025 and coverage as of December 31, 2025; anything marked n/a the report does not print.

Watch flags

Computed from the Citigroup Commercial Mortgage Trust 2016-C2 filing for the reporting period ending October 13, 2026, filed with the SEC October 26, 2026.

  • With the special servicer
  • Coverage below 1.00x
  • Past maturity

cmbs.news's own rule-based labels on the filed fields (definitions), not a credit rating, a prediction or a view of the borrower.

What the filing shows

  • Net operating income is 20% below the underwritten figure ($2.8M a year against $3.5M).
  • At 0.99x, the property's reported NOI does not cover its debt service.

What these trusts report, and what they do not

CSAIL 2016-C6 Commercial Mortgage Trust and Citigroup Commercial Mortgage Trust 2016-C2 were issued before Regulation AB II's loan-level reporting began in late 2016, so they file no ABS-EE asset data. Each trust's certificate administrator files a distribution statement with each monthly 10-D, and that statement lists every loan. This page reads those statements, checked against their own totals, and the trusts' prospectuses for the property.

  • From the 10-D, each month: balance, interest rate, maturity, paid-through date, payment status, whether the loan is on the specially serviced list, net operating income and its dates, appraisal reductions, modifications, workout strategy and the special servicer's comments.
  • From the prospectus (Annex A-1), as of securitization: the property's name, address and type, its size, year built, appraised value, underwritten income and coverage, the original balance and terms, the originator and the largest tenants.
  • Not reported for this trust: the monthly figures a Schedule AL tape carries and its 10-D leaves out, such as current occupancy, coverage for loans not with the special servicer, each property's current figures in a portfolio, defeasance status, and the largest tenants now. Where this page shows n/a, the report does not print it.
  • Not offered yet for this trust's loans: the 12-month report history and loan alerts, which need the trust's reports compared month against month.

Source: the trust's 10-D report of October 19, 2026 (filing index). How these trusts are read.

What the special servicer reports

Transferred
April 7, 2026
Resolution strategy
Full Payoff
Comment dated
October 13, 2026
  • Forbearance
  • Payoff or refinance

10/13/2026Jay Scutti Plaza is a 288,971 SF strip mall located at 300 & 1000 Hylan Drive, Henrietta, NY 14623. It was built in 1987.

Excerpt of the special servicer's comment in the CSAIL 2016-C6 Commercial Mortgage Trust trustee report, filed with the SEC October 28, 2026. The full comment is in the filing.

Appraisal reduction and advances

Appraisal reduction
$9,087,332, June 11, 2026
Cumulative ASER
$14,684 (interest the servicer stopped advancing because of the reduction)

From the trust's monthly trustee report. An appraisal reduction cuts how much interest the servicer advances to bondholders when a loan's new appraisal falls short.

Refinance test on today's income

The latest annual NOI in the filing is $2.8M, a debt yield of 7.9% on $36.0M. Lenders often size a new loan so NOI is at least 9% to 10% of the loan amount.

Debt yield a lender requiresLargest loanAgainst today's balance
9%$31.4M $4.6M short
10%$28.3M $7.7M short

Arithmetic on the filed NOI only: no rates, reserves, cap rates or lender terms. NOI can be a year old; see the statement dates above.

Refinance and early payoff, at today's rates

This estimate uses today's Treasury curve and needs JavaScript.

Rough estimates, not quotes. New loan: the filed NOI divided by the coverage you set, at the Treasury yield for the term plus your spread. Early payoff: the present value of the remaining scheduled payments to the open date at today's Treasury yields, less the balance, which is roughly what defeasance or yield maintenance costs. Loan documents, fees and the securities bought change the real number. Treasury yields: U.S. Treasury daily par curve.

Where the loan sits

The loan is split into 2 notes held by different trusts. Each trust reports its own piece.

Property Location Type Balance Rate Matures DSCR Occ. Status
Nearby retail loans
BJS Rochester, NY Henrietta, NY Retail $9.0M 4.27% May 2031 2.14x 100% Current
Towne Center at Webster Webster, NY Retail $43.0M 7.335% Aug 2029 1.00x 98% Current
Webster Plaza Webster, NY Retail $11.1M 7.21% Nov 2032 1.63x 85% Current
Shoppes at Westgate Rochester, NY Retail $4.0M 6.55% Apr 2030 3.00x 91% Current
Walgreens Williamson Williamson, NY Retail $3.3M 4.187% Oct 2030 n/a n/a With the special servicer and 90+ days delinquent

Source: the trust's monthly 10-D report (Exhibit 99.1) on SEC EDGAR, for the distribution of October 19, 2026, and its prospectus (Annex A-1) for the property and its figures at securitization. Servicers report these figures; cmbs.news does not audit them. How this page is built.

Something wrong with this loan?